mysngoeshere56 (post: 1390093) wrote:No problem. ^_^
Anyway, I'm looking for some stuff to expand my manga realm a bit too... I'm pretty picky, but when I find something I like, I really like it.
Here's the kind of stuff I'm looking for: something slightly dark, melancholy, maybe a little gothic, but I also want something with some lightheartedness and romance too (NOTE: different manga with with just one aspect or another are wonderful (though if just one or the other, I lean toward the first). manga with both is perfect.)
Here's just a tad bit of what I've read with aspects of what I'm looking for, to give you a glimpse of what I'm looking for...
Angelic Layer - It's not my favorite of all time, but I always thought it was cute. I wasn't exactly finding the concept something exceptional, but the romance and family values in it made it a winner for me. I liked the anime quite a bit, but I just can't get into the manga for some reason. I think it's because the artwork isn't as good. I've read/watched a lot of CLAMP stuff, so I know the artwork isn't nearly as good as it could've been.
Cardcaptor Sakura - I've only read a bit of the manga, but I do like the little bit I read. I watched and enjoyed the entire anime, if that counts for anything.
D.N.Angel - My favorite manga. One of the two that also got me into manga.
Full Moon wo Sagashite - I haven't read much, but what I've read so far has been great.
Fullmetal Alchemist - I haven't read much of the manga, but I like the anime quite a bit. I plan on catching up on the manga once I have the time.
Fruits Basket - Could do without some language in the Tokyopop version, but that aside, it's my favorite shojo series of all time.
Goth - Excellent idea for a story, but all the gruesome moments made it a tad too much for me. I'm perfectly fine with violence, but this crossed my limits a bit. I probably would've been able to take it in a novel (or longer, with the SUPER gruesome moments pushed so they're few and far between), but since this is manga, I felt it was too much. And the fact that the potential romance between the two main characters wasn't focused on much was another drawback for me (not that I expected it to be all "lovey dovey", but it would've been nice if it was touched on a bit more). Wouldn't have finished if it was over 1 volume.
Mermaid Melody Pichi Pichi Pitch - Overall, a horrid manga by my standards. But still, it had sweet moments that were worth noting... I liked some of the nice moments between the mermaids and their lovers, but other than that, I couldn't stand reading it... I only finished it because I'm typically too curious to find out how it all turns out.
Tsubasa RESERVoir CHRoNiCLE - My other favorite, and the other one that got me into manga.
Rurouni Kenshin - Another good one. Definitely an exciting shonen story!
Vampire Knight - One of the best I've read of all time, and a nice blend between melancholy and romance.
I can take most language, but what I dislike most is the use of the Lord's name in vain. Sexual content and nudity I can tolerate, depending on the degree and frequency. If there is any objectionable religious content, just let me know and I can see if it's forgivable or not by my standards.
Mr. Hat'n'Clogs (post: 1390115) wrote: xxxHolic is by CLAMP, whom you seem to like, and seems like something that fits your criteria. I can't tell you about content, because I've only read the first volume.
Wyntre Rose (post: 1390117) wrote:Oh, and don't let the fangirls fool you. This isn't a yaoi/shounen ai series.
Lynna (post: 1391688) wrote:I would like a manga recommendations!
As you can see, I read mostly shojo, but theres a few exceptions. what I would like is a manga with good characters and a deep and interesting plot...although it doesn't necisarily have to be that.
Thank you!!
Mr. Hat'n'Clogs (post: 1391691) wrote:So now it's my turn. With the completion of Solanin, I've needed a new manga to read. Similar criteria, preferably not the length of JoJo's or One Piece, Blade of the Immortal is about the level of content I mind. If it's worse the BotI, I probably would mind, but I'm fine with BotI, so it'll probably be fine for whatever you recommend, as long as it isn't Berserk.
Manga I've Liked:
If you couldn't tell, I kind of like that one FMA thing.
Yotsuba&!
Solanin
Azumanga Daioh
Blade of the Immortal
Tegami Bachi:Letter Bee
Ouran High School Host Club
Soul Eater
On a final note, I do plan on reading 20th Century Boys once I have monies for buying it.
You would dig Battle Angel Alita. I haven't kept up with it in a while, but it's universally regarded as a classic. I remember the first 3 volumes being outstanding (plus if you read this, Falx will be your friend forever). It's dark cyberpunk w/ depth and a bit o' the old violence. Now that I am thinking about it, I'll probably go and read my copies... =)Mr. Hat'n'Clogs (post: 1391691) wrote:I've needed a new manga to read.
Atria35 (post: 1391709) wrote:Wow. All over the place
If you like Yotsuba&, you might also like Bunny Drop.
Solanin brings to mind Seizon -Life-, Adventure Boys, and A Distant Neighborhood (aka Harukana Machi-E).
Azu Dai and Ouran? Perhaps Bamboo Blade would also be your speed.
I'm also not familiar with Blade of the Immortal's content, so I'm going to leave it at that.
TheSubtleDoctor (post: 1391713) wrote:You would dig Battle Angel Alita. I haven't kept up with it in a while, but it's universally regarded as a classic. I remember the first 3 volumes being outstanding (plus if you read this, Falx will be your friend forever). It's dark cyberpunk w/ depth and a bit o' the old violence. Now that I am thinking about it, I'll probably go and read my copies... =)
It's only 9 volumes, and yeah it's Viz. BAA: Second Order is currently still being made, tho. Viz has the first dozen or so translated and for sale.Mr. Hat'n'Clogs (post: 1391720) wrote:BAA sounds pretty cool, even if it is long, and I probably should have thought of this. It's a Viz license, right?
impact777 (post: 1396240) wrote:I'm a totally newbie on the manga sector. The only manga I've read so far is Yotsuba, and I love it. Could you please recommend me some manga? I think I like all genres. I don't like "bad religion" and nudity. Thanks a lot.
PatrickEklektos (post: 1402184) wrote:Hey, I am trying to find good manga forto learn the style and thereby write. But I don't want just trash. So I have been looking high and low for a good one. Something without perversion. I tried code geass until I found somethings about it so I can't stand it anymore. Now I am looking at .hack though bro said that it ended weird. Is the manga good? Do you all have any other recommendations... sci-fi meybe? action? perhaps fantasy? I dunno. Oh, and no demons, vampires, or magic.
SDG
PatrickEklektos (post: 1402184) wrote:Hey, I am trying to find good manga forto learn the style and thereby write. But I don't want just trash. So I have been looking high and low for a good one.
Do you all have any other recommendations... sci-fi meybe? action? perhaps fantasy? I dunno. Oh, and no demons, vampires, or magic.
PatrickEklektos (post: 1402305) wrote:So... LOTR had no magic... I kinda figure it can be done. LOL
SDG
blkmage (post: 1402319) wrote:My problem with people putting Tolkien's work on a pedestal as a work of good Christian fantasy is that property of his work is not immediately obvious. I'll concede that it probably is, but a simple reading of it would not lead you to that conclusion. Rather, it takes an incredible amount of literary analysis before you understand the worldview he's trying to present through his works. And it seems to me that people are unwilling to take the same kind of effort into analysing other works before deciding whether they're good or not.
blkmage (post: 1402319) wrote:The argument that the Middle Earth mythos does not contain magic is a technicality, in that even if it's not called magic or mentioned explicitly, that mechanic still functions in the role of magic in a fantasy setting. It's like saying Fullmetal Alchemist doesn't have any magic]not immediately obvious[/I]. I'll concede that it probably is, but a simple reading of it would not lead you to that conclusion. Rather, it takes an incredible amount of literary analysis before you understand the worldview he's trying to present through his works. And it seems to me that people are unwilling to take the same kind of effort into analysing other works before deciding whether they're good or not.
MasterDias (post: 1402323) wrote:PatrickEklektos, try Rurouni Kenshin. It's a good action title, and it makes a solid introduction to manga. It has nothing that could be interpreted as "magic."
PatrickEklektos (post: 1402327) wrote:That looks AWESOME!!! I just checked out the review and it looks perfect! I am going to try to find it today! Thanks!!!
SDG
Return to Manga and Manga Reviews
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 32 guests